12233 Poway Rd, Poway, CA    858-513-3000


Welcome to Coney Island Pizzeria, authentic New York style pizza in Poway, California.

We exclusively use imported Italian tomatoes and New York cheese, and our pies are made on New York stone ovens. Our authentic New York style pizza recipe originated on the west side of Bronx, New York and was mastered over three generations and perfected by a Sicilian Master Pizzaiolo. We are a proud, family-owned and operated Pizzeria dedicated to bringing you only the best- because to us, you're family.

Stop by for lunch or dinner, or let us cater your next event.

We're now delivering, up to 5 miles with a $20 minimum order.

See MENU & Order

Coney Island Pizzeria is the home of Poway's Best Pizza and was voted top five for "Best Pizza" in San Diego County for three years on San Diego A-List. Coney Island Pizzeria was founded over a decade ago by a "true" New Yorker and his buddy, an Italian Master Pizzaiolo. Needless to say it was a great hit from the get go, but eventually these buddies left to take on the big city and do bigger things.

Unfortunately, throughout the years, little Coney Island went through several hands that nearly drove it into the ground. Till one happy spring day, on the 1st of March 2013, it landed in the hands of our family.

Coney Island Pizzeria is now family owned and operated, serving THE BEST Pies in town. At Coney, our family serves your family only the finest ingredients. Just like back east, we proudly make our pies with the best cheeses in the country, along with the finest Italian tomatoes we can allocate in the country.

No, we don't import our water from back east- that's just silly tales- but through a little science and 15 years of experience, our head Pizzaiolo (dad), aka "cook," aka "that pizza guy," has mastered an amazing dough with an even balance of chew and crispness that is nearly impossible to do with California tap water. We take our Pizza seriously because Pizza is what we do! You may find our menu a little tight, without a lot of other shenanigans, but we will make you the best pie in town before your eyes.


Wednesday - Friday11am-8pm
Sunday 4pm-8pm

Now Delivering!
Up to 5 miles with a $20 minimum order

12233 Poway Road
Poway, CA 92064